The film American Beauty and its relation to Plato and the philosophical pursuit of true Beauty in modern society...
American Beauty illustrates the dangers of conventionality, while also expressing a collective human tendency towards it, illustrating this through those who yearn to fit in to the collective societal definition of what is beautiful, as well as those who have risen above such narcissistic and materialistic tendencies. Rather than making a distinction between these seemingly taboo desires for beauty, American Beauty focuses on the violent repercussions of their denial. Lester’s character illustrates the danger of beauty being perceived as a corporeal phenomenon and only through the eye of the beholder, whereas Ricky’s character highlights the virtues of beauty being an intrinsic property and perceiving it in an intellectual manner. The purpose and main message of the movie is not to document the downfalls of contemporary American society, but so show that even in a world of utter ugliness and familial strife, there is beauty to be found everywhere.
The theme of American Beauty centers on the redemption of one man's soul. Beauty in this case has transformed an individual's consciousness first on a physical level, and eventually within the spiritual level as well. Lester’s discovery of the beautiful and subsequent realization of true beauty first occurs with his initial encounter with Angela, and culminates in his realization that his daughter’s happiness can fill him with the most joy a father can experience. Lester’s first encounter with, and subsequent pursuit of, Angela is much like Plato’s quandary of the two reactions one faces in an encounter with True Beauty, illustrated in his example of the charioteer and the two horses: “Now he who is not newly initiated or who has become corrupted, does not easily rise out of this world to the sight of true beauty in the other; he looks only at her earthly namesake, and instead of being awed at the sight of her, he is given over to pleasure, and like a brutish beat he rushes on to enjoy and beget.” According to Plato, our initial, base and more primal desire is to possess and conquer beauty in whatever way possible, but he advocates the more restrained and respectful approach that is seen in the other of the two horses. Nevertheless, Lester’s encounter with Angela, the clearest and most easily-perceived example of conventional beauty presented in the film, sparks his body’s spiritual awakening and his soul’s eventual remembrance of True Beauty beyond this earth. Though it ultimately leads to his death, Lester is first redeemed through the awakening knowledge of his own repression and middle class angst.
Colonel Frank is a very stern and overpowering father who utilizes anger and even violence to discipline Ricky for the smallest of missteps. Frank’s wife always appears incoherent, distant, detached, or even mentally disturbed throughout the film: her life has been apparently devoid of happiness for so long, no doubt due to her husband’s regiments and denial, that she has quite literally ceased to function in a world in which she is no longer able to find the beauty. Ricky and his father both possess secrets, which are both actually on display for all to see, though in a hidden manner through display cases and video boxes. The notion of power and family structure in this film is shown in many ways concerning beauty: Frank Fitts has power over his son, Ricky, only because he is able to beat him and control his surroundings to an extent. But Ricky has a larger, more influential kind of power over society in general because of his ability to twist his father’s restrictive and principled methods into an approach to appreciating beauty, rather than controlling or harnessing it. When viewed in this way, it is clear to the audience that Ricky is in the ranks not only of the greatest philosophers, but also among those divine objects of beauty with which he is so enthralled.
Initially, Ricky comes across as a creep who video-tapes either people without their consent, or disturbing images that other people find to be far from beautiful. Through his relationship and self-disclosure with Jane, we come to find that he is actually quite a normal person who possesses a different, if not enviable, way of viewing the world. He analyzes that which he perceives to be beautiful very deeply and puts a lot of thought into everything that he does. Ricky’s initial portrayal of a voyeur that is outside of the societal norm becomes a glimpse into the discipline and virtue of a modern-day philosopher. The aim of a philosopher is to see things for beyond what the physically are, all the while operating under ridiculous constraints in a kind of mad and unrealistic manner. Ricky Fitts, essentially practices his philosophy through a video camera in this film, and subsequently becomes very influential to others in film, especially in regards to their own pursuits of beauty. Ricky explains his experience of the beautiful as though God is looking at him for a moment through the object he is video-taping. Ricky’s experience with the beautiful is profound because he regards his enchantment with the physical world only as a means to the divine one. In speaking about his videos to Jane, Ricky says, “Sometimes there's so much beauty in the world I feel like I can't take it... and my heart is going to cave in.” While Ricky’s description of the 15 minute “dance” he had with a plastic bag on a precariously snowy day is one of the most articulate and profound descriptions of beauty in the film, it is his relationship with Jane that best illustrates Plato’s notion of how to approach and appreciate that which we find to be truly beautiful on this earth: “And now they are at the spot and behold the flashing beauty of the beloved; which when the charioteer sees, his memory is carried to the true beauty, whom he beholds in company with Modesty like an image placed upon a holy pedestal. He sees her, but he is afraid and falls backward in adoration.” Interacting with Jane solely through a camera lens, as well as a window and mirror at times, not only illustrates Ricky’s respect for and appreciation of the Beautiful, but shows Jane how special he actually perceives her to be, which leads to a heightening and strengthening of their relationship.
In the Phaedrus, Plato speaks of ideals, and to understand the soul in its ideal form, we must contemplate beauty to learn more about the soul. Plato saw the physical world as a poor, decaying copy of a rational, perfect, eternal and changeless original. But while he dictated this, he acknowledged that one can only catch glimpses of beauty itself through images of fading perfection found here on earth. Ricky is the best example of this Platonic notion, as he strives to see the beauty in things that allude, confuse, or disturb others around him. He makes no apologies to the collective who find him strange and manages to elude the rigid constraints of his father’s household in order to pursue his endeavor. Plato asserted that the best human life is one that strives for understanding and copying the forms as closely as possible, which Ricky does from a removed and respectable distance with his video recorder. Plato also makes many warnings against confusing one’s ability to see with one’s ability to perceive the beautiful: “For sight is the most piercing of our bodily senses; though not by that is wisdom seen; her loveliness would have been transporting if there had been a visible image of her, and the other ideas, if they had visible counterparts, would be equally lovely.” While the sense of sight is privileged because it is the only way with which we may gain access to the individual, it is actually in the ideal of knowing true beauty that the soul encountered from another time which defines a perception of true beauty for Plato.
Plotinus would suggest that Ricky’s principled and ritualized life, as well as the ways in which he documents and experiences beauty, put him on a level with the most noble of scholars: “Therefore the Soul must be trained—to the habit of remarking, first, all noble pursuits, then the works of beauty produced not by the labor of the arts but by the virtue of men known for their goodness; lastly, you must search the souls of those that have shaped these beautiful forms.” Hillman, author of the Practice of Beauty would also approve of Ricky’s discipline in his practice and pursuits of beauty, yet he would also advocate a risking of excess and uncontrollable emotion that Lester seems to indulge in from time to time. For Hillman, such maddening feelings and desires are beauty, and to him it should be acted upon before thought too much about. It is his manifesto against irony to not repress feelings automatically, but rather to be free and natural and unafraid to experience emotion, and therefore unafraid to experience beauty and all it has to offer.
The collective or societal tendency to treat beauty as an unnecessary indulgence is grounded more in preventative measures than in actual reason. Beauty, even in its Truest form always involves desires, more specifically eliciting said desires from society, which in turn tries to regulate this awakening because the pursuit of an object of beauty usually becomes all-encompassing. This trait of beauty has always led to a fear for the crumbling of society as a whole at the hands of an ignoble pursuit. American Beauty, in a way, takes the long, arduous writings of philosophers on the subject of beauty and applies it to our modern society. Through forcing the audience to examine their lives more closely, challenging the more sacred and unspoken rules of suburbia along the way, this film tears apart societal notions of beauty that require conformity, and instead opens up a chance for the viewer to develop a greater understanding for what is truly beautiful in the world.
In Uncontrollable Beauty, Lester’s initially inappropriate responses to the object which he finds beautiful can be better explained through basic human instinct, and primal desire overtaking rational though,t: “Most people still feel in the presence of beauty that old wish to do something, whether it is to make love to the beautiful person…in any case, nothing satisfies the impulse but merely exhausts it. The perception of beauty wears out after a while, speeded up by activity. Remembered beauty, on the other hand, if protected properly, can be a source of light and heat to ones imagination and ones sense of life, like the sun shining in on ones shoulder.” Such an ignorance of or preoccupation with beauty is commonly associated with the male experience of beauty, but in Lester’s case was most likely triggered by his family’s repression of their feelings towards beauty. However, the moment where Lester almost possesses Angela is presented as a kind of façade, as his erotic new facility by which to gain enlightenment was useful, though ultimately misguided: Nevertheless, he eventually understands his role as a father and protector of beauty, as he tries to not to possess her, but ultimately retain a more philosophical relation to the object.
American Beauty is about discovering that beauty can be found within the differences and stimulating novelty of things, rather than the conformity and repetition of societal ideals. Lester’s mid-life crisis and apparent boredom with life in general is a symptom of a life led without acknowledging or being able to perceive beauty, as illustrated in Survival of the Prettiest: “Beauty is a basic pleasure…the balance of response to physical beauty is one sign of profound depression.” Lester Burnham lives in a façade of the American dream. He is stuck in a career he hates, a family he cannot relate to, and in a rut of boredom that lands him in a full-blown mid-life crisis. His passionless marriage to Carolyn highlights the repercussions of her materialistic perfectionism, which may have secured their family a normal outward appearance, but has left the individuals within said collective both unfulfilled and unhappy with life in general, showing that a superficial notion of beauty does not have the same benefits as an inherent understanding of true beauty. American society has a tendency to be deeply rooted in a notion that we are defined by what we possess. This is a superficial notion of our society that entrenches a middle-aged Lester Burnham in the film, American Beauty. While he is able to recognize the trouble and fakeness surrounding his family, he chooses to avoid it because he would rather not disturb the perfect image that they present to society. And while his wife works tirelessly to maintain this façade in hopes of convincing the world that they are a perfect and normal family, this fails miserably as her family only suffers worse for her efforts, and she herself is hopelessly frustrated and unhappy. The fact that Lester is surrounded by artificiality is the ironic precursor to his impulsive and life-changing decisions. Eventually, after multiple displays of cynicism, irreverence and sarcasm, Lester Burnham presents his first genuine smile upon hearing that his daughter is in love. He pronounces simply "I'm happy for her," and in that moment, he is able to find the good in a world that he's spent so much time ignoring or rejecting. Even within a society that espouses so many values he hates, in a world that has destroyed so many of the people around him, his greatest realization is that he is able to surprise himself, ignore others when necessary, and find the Beauty in the simplest of things.